Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone: Gay Marriage, “It’s My Duty to Speak Up”

We have Failed to Teach the Treasures of Traditional
Marriage Adequately to Our Young People

Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone’s Interview with the San Francisco Chronicle


1. You have been at the forefront of the same-sex marriage debate in California and nationally. You helped raise money for Prop 8, got evangelical congregations involved and campaigned heavily for it. Should the Supreme Court legalize same-sex marriage in California in June, what would your next move be?

I am a pastor and a teacher of the faith. It is responsibility to educate, motivate and inspire people to live by the truths of the Gospel, including using the blessed power we have as free citizens in a democracy to work for justice and compassion in the public square, and so contribute to the common good. When a great public issue like the meaning of marriage arises, of course, it’s my duty as a pastor to speak up. That job description won’t change regardless of any Supreme Court decision. But since the law is also a teacher, when it teaches an untruth (e.g., people of a certain race are inferior to others and can be treated as such, human life in the womb is not worthy of equal respect, or that two people of the same sex can make a marriage with each other) my job gets harder, but it doesn’t change: we need to work every day in our homes, in our parishes and in our communities to rebuild a marriage culture. Too many children are being hurt by our culture’s strange and increasing inability to appreciate how important it is to bring together mothers and fathers for children in one loving home. The basic question is: does our society need an institution that connects children to their mothers and fathers, or doesn’t it? The only institution that does this is marriage. Redefining marriage will mean that our society will have given its definitive answer: “no”; it will mean changing the basic understanding of marriage from a child-centered institution to one that sees it as a temporary, revocable commitment which prioritizes the romantic happiness of adults over building a loving, lasting family. This would result in the law teaching that children do not need an institution that connects them to the mother and father who brought them into the world and their mother and father to each other. Priority number one for me will continue to be looking for new ways to inspire Catholics to live their faith and help rebuild a more loving and successful marriage culture.

2. Why do you think that the Catholic Church should be spending money, time and resources on the same sex marriage battle, when it could be directing those resources toward helping the victims of the rapidly increasing poverty rate? How high of a priority should it be for the Church?

Marriage and poverty are deeply intertwined concerns: an extremely high percentage of people in poverty are from broken families, and when the family breaks up it increases the risk of sliding into poverty, with single parents (usually mothers) making heroic sacrifices for their children as they struggle to fulfill the role of both mother and father. And beyond material poverty there is that poverty of the spirit in which kids hunger for their missing parent, who often seems absent and disengaged from their lives. We all have a deep instinct for connectedness to where we came from, and we deeply desire it when we do not have it.
Promoting stable marriages is actually one of the best things we can do to help eradicate poverty; in fact, it is a necessary, even if by itself alone not a sufficient, part of the solution – that is, we cannot hope to fix the problem without it. The solution to poverty certainly requires a multi-faceted strategy; we need efforts such as job training and placement for those in poverty, quality education for at risk youth, and so on. My Church is also involved in many of these kinds of efforts. But neither are these efforts alone sufficient. To focus exclusively on this, without educating our young people for marriage – teaching them to desire marriage and to develop the virtue necessary to sustain the demanding but rewarding commitment of marriage – would be like putting a bandage on a mortal wound. Rebuilding a marriage culture in which both men and women understand they need to come together in marriage to raise their children is not a distraction from poverty, it’s one necessary part of helping to alleviate poverty.

3. After Rhode Island approved same-sex marriage, you said it was “a great injustice.” But an ABC News poll in March found that 54 percent of Catholics now support same-sex marriage, mirroring other national surveys. Young people are firmly in support of same-sex marriage. Twelve states now allow it. The largest Catholic country, Brazil, has legalized it, as has France. With the Catholic Church attendance shrinking in the U.S., doesn’t the Church’s overt leadership on this issue risk alienating young people? What would you say to a young person — Catholic or otherwise — who is put off by the Church’s stance on this position?

Well, we have a lot of work to do, don’t we? Of course many people these days self-identify as Catholic on surveys like these without actually doing basic Catholic things like attending Mass on Sunday. Many people call themselves Catholic because that is the religion they grew up with and, indeed, they are Catholic, but many are also quite distant from the Church and know little of what their Church really teaches and why. The Catholic Church has been dealing with marriage far more than any other institution in the world: For 2,000 years we have reflected on the importance of marriage for the common good, we have reflected on it theologically and reflected on its mystical significance, we have legislated on it (in fact, much of our civil legislation on marriage came from the Church’s canon law, e.g., the principle that it is the consent of the couple that establishes their marriage and not anything else, such as a contract between their fathers) and we have been engaged on the pastoral level. We certainly have a valuable voice to contribute to this discussion, and, quite frankly, our insights are quite profound, even though it is quite difficult to break through the dominant culture to get this message out to people, especially young people. What I would say to a young person is: “open your mind! I have a treasure to share with you! If you receive it with an open mind and heart your life will be changed, and for the better!” My experience, and that of others I know who work in this field, has been that when young people are exposed to this deeper significance of marriage, and get in touch with their true, deeper desires, they enthusiastically embrace the Church’s teaching. In fact, the most common remark one hears is, “Why didn’t anyone tell me this before? It would have saved me untold heartache.” And this points to the real problem, which is the fault of us pastors: we have failed to teach this adequately to our young people. That’s why they are distracted by the false messages of the popular culture.

4. Have you met with any gays or parents of gay children since you came to San Francisco so as to better understand their perspective?

Yes, I’ve met privately with gay people when we’ve tried to get to know each other and each other’s points of view better. I cherish that kind of one-on-one dialogue because it puts a human face on our disagreements, and that makes it harder for hatred to grow. I haven’t yet done this in my first eight months here in this archdiocese.


Here is an added bonuses of Fr. Joseph Shea homily . . .  It’s very good.


P.S. – Would you do Courageous Priest a favor and share this info with your friends on Facebook, Twitter or Email right now? We truly appreciate it. Or leave a comment, we would love to hear what you think.

5 comments to Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone: Gay Marriage, “It’s My Duty to Speak Up”

  • It’s time to return of the Baltimore catechist. The catechist never change. I grow up with the teaching of the Baltimore catechist which is the Truth.

  • Thank God for AB Cordileone for being the Truth Shepard of our church and for his courage to speak
    clearly about marriage-sorry to say we have so few that would stand up for this in public.
    Couragious priest you are and faithful catholics are fortunate to have you for their strong voice in
    San Francisco.
    Thank you Holy Spirit for the words this Archbishop speaks for your holy sacrament!
    Matt from Seattle

  • Jean Noel

    God is both mercy and justice. However before mercy is granted, contrition based upon realization of one’s sins is necessary—Jesus to the woman at the well, “Go and sin no more.” Justice demands that contrition/true repentance comes first. Read the Gospels. Jesus allowed many to walk away because they could not accept His ways or words.

  • Teresa

    Well said Tim Rohr!! Very well said. You are spot on with every single point. I know, because I LIVED IT!! The CCD programs for our children that taught them HERESY!! And parents were left holding the bag and trying to instill the CORRECT teaching of the Catholic Church and LIVE the correct teaching, and we would hear….but Mom, my teacher said….. at one point in time, I was down at the Parish Office taking them APART!! In my opinion they absolutely SABOTAGED traditional Catholic parents! I live in deceased Cardinal Bernadine’s Diocese so I have first hand knowledge of what it is you are speaking, Tim. The heresy was beyond the beyond. And YES, I am angry. My child (which by now is a grown adult with children) is a bonafied Cafeteria Catholic that I STILL CANNOT talk real Catholic Doctrine to, but at least, I guess the family is in Church. (not every Sunday mind you because they were told to miss Mass is NOT MORTALLY SINFUL) Look at the millions of souls they have led down the wrong path, right into the hands of Satan himself, and tell me who wouldn’t be LIVID!!

    And to the people who think we need not offend and show the utmost compassion to homosexual oriented people, don’t we already do that? I have NEVER KNOWN ANYONE in our Church to be anything but warm and welcoming to these people. That does not mean that we should not teach the truth. Is it not more charitable to teach truth than to allow souls to be lost? TRUTH IS CHARITY. Of course you do not single people out, but you TEACH THE TRUTH OF THE CHURCH so the seed may be planted! Gray is an UGLY COLOR…..IT IS SATAN’S FAVORITE! The Priests who teach heresy have a rude awakening on Judgement Day. We have long ago learned that we need to keep our eyes open for ‘wolves in sheep’s clothing.’ There are many of them.

  • TG

    Very good answers. We need to hear a homily like that. Priests wouldn’t have to use strong language to actually teach the teachings of the church. It can be done just like the Archbishop did here.

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>